To the monograph's contents
Asmara & Carrara
Chapter 4

Asmara and Carrara through the Ages, the Burden of the Past, the Promise of the Future

In the early 1930s, Silvio Fruzzetti leaves Carrara like many Italians in search of work heading to the colonies. He emigrates to Eritrea which at that time was already a rapidly developing colony with its capital Asmara, in its later phase of expansion, in industrial, residential, and communication by roads, a railway linking the major towns in the different regions of the country. There were employment opportunities especially in the roads been built to join towns and villages. The society he finds is divided between Italians and the local people who far outnumber the colonizers. The port city of Massawa is also linked by train to move goods to Asmara and beyond. There is a significant Italian presence in all the major country towns with their own local administrative setup linked to the capital city. Up to the introduction of Mussolini’s racial laws, Italians freely intermarry local women but all along enter common-law alliances and establish families. Chapter four extends the family discussions of the previous chapters to include the younger generations, grandchildren of Silvio and Lucia in Carrara and Asmara. It also explores the history and experiences of the extended family members in Europe children of Lucia’s elder brothers Berhane and Mehari, the former living in Sweden and the latter in Germany. In Carrara, we include the descendants of Silvio’s Italian family, as well as his sister Maria’s and brother Andrea’s. The substance of these conversations goes beyond family matters and dispositions to embrace the contexts of local history as well as reflections on the world beyond the locality. There are generational differences in the definitions and meaning and value of family, relatives, friends, and workplace relationships.

Here we create the widest context for the families previously discussed to include the relation to politics, history, and nationalism. Some of the contents come from the recorded interviews in family members' own words, but there are also interviews with local historians, politicians, artists, workers, miners. In addition, the carefully chosen linked sources range far beyond to include existing and found archival and library materials in Italy as well as Asmara. There are links to other primary and secondary print sources and commented bibliographies relating to colonialism, imperialism before WW2, in Italian and English materials gleaned from diasporas, recent revisionist as well as radical/progressive histories.

Map of Italy from the 1920s
Map of Eritrea from the 1920s

Italy and Eritrea during Colonial Times

January 1, 1890, Italy occupied Eritrea as a colony, fulfilling their dream of a ‘place under
the sun’, it occupied the rest of Eritrea by 1899. Eritrea also known as ‘Colonia Primogenita,
hosted large numbers of Italian settlers, marked by their expansion of the cemeteries and
building of Mausoleums, especially in Massawa and Asmara, later followed by Keren and
Barentu. Despite the large numbers of Muslim communities, the Italians were able to spread
and encourage Catholicism, building of churches and missions.
With the coming of Mussolini in1922, some drastic changes did take place, expansions of lands,
and along with other colonies such as Somaliland establishing ‘Africa Orientale Italiana’, making
Eritrea the new industrial center of Italian East Africa’

The second world war did affect Italians in their colonies with the defeat of the Italians
by the British. The Italian presence in Eritrea came to an end in 1941, when the country became
a UN mandate in 1951, establishing Eritrea as an autonomous region within Ethiopia. In 1952
Ethiopia fully annexed Eritrea as a province, leading to the thirty-year civil war, and mass
exodus of the population into Sudan. Winning the war in 1991, Eritrea became an independent
country in 1993.
Acknowledging the scholarly work of Joe Russell

Asmara, Eritrea Asmara, Eritrea
Carrara, Italy Carrara, Italy

Asmara and Carrara two cities in world perspective

A walk through Asmara’s patrimony commented by Daniel Berhane

Daniel Berhane, a long time resident and unofficial historian, guides us through historical and contemporary Asmara. He participated in the EPLF thirty-years struggle for independence.

A walk through Carrara patrimony commented by Mario Venutelli

Mario Venutelli long-time president of Italia Nostra guides us around Carrara and explores the city's patrimony. Italia Nostra is a national cultural organization that plans and runs cultural activities.

Local Journalists and Historians

Journalist Giorgio Lindi historical and cultural critic of Carrara

Giorgio Lindi cultural and political critic talks about Carrara's uniqueness. A highly respected progressive writer on Carrara's past and present with particular emphasis on the role of anarchism and syndicalism.

Journalist Simone Caffaz, conservative historian of Carrara and its surroundings Carrara

Simone Caffaz is the author of many books including Luna Caput Mundi on Carrara's Roman past to Renato Ricci, member of Mussolini's Gran Consiglio.

Partisan Francesco Gobi

Francesco Gobi was the youngest among the Partisans fighting the Nazis in the Carrara region. His brigade sought action from the collapse of the Fascist regime to Liberation of Italy.

Maria Mattei left progressive politician in Carrara

Despite women's leading role in the Resistance (1942), Mattei reflects on the absence of women in contemporary politics and elected offices.

Historian Gino Vatteroni on Carrara’s Anarchist History Vatteroni's political activism is matched by his research and writing about anarchists among Carrara's marble workers. A task that took him to the immigrant marble workers in Vermont, artists and anarchists who developed American marble industry. Testament to their work are many monuments in New York and Washington.
download transcript ENG
A chance encounter with Agnese Fruzzetti’s cousin Maria Zini and her husband Alberto in Barcelona

Alberto comments on the significance of Mussolini's botched attempt to overcome the Resistance Movement in Carrara. He achieved the modicum of success by creating near starvation among the population.

Discussion with the younger (second generation) members of the family

Bruna Zini on family, unconditional love, protection, collaboration and cooperation; within family there is true love and friendship

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Silvia, daughter of cousin Paola and her husband Enzo, on the meaning of family

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Matteo Ferrari (son of Lina’s first cousin Michele), on the meaning of family

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Manuel Castagli, son of Pietrina Ferrari, on family in rural areas, extended family, deeply rooted culture in family. Effects of modernization, loss of family values today, adoption for homosexual families

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Alessandra Zini on affection and nuclear family, strong bond with family members, marriage and pension, and homosexual unions. Recoding family moments, collecting pictures.

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Arcolini Walter Daniele on the unity of his family members and Italian multi ethnic society

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Christian Ferrari on blood ties, affective feeling with particular people, and the importance of embracing diversity.

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Maria Luna, wife of Christian Ferrari, on the meaning of family

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Raffaella Badiale on being an only child, the relationship with her mother and father, and the lack of laws supporting homosexual couples in Italy.

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

A group of artists revive Carrara's ancient art of sculpting in marble

Mirco Ferrari: marble cave developer

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Zoran, French marble sculptor and artist living and working in Carrara

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Osama, Sculptor and Visionary

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Butrus, Monumental Sculptor

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Emanuele, Studio and Gallery Owner

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG

Dominik Stroban

download transcript Download Transcript -  ENG
Marble Mines in Carrara

Old Quarries

Anarchist Monuments, Posters in Carrara

Cemeteries in Keren

Cemeteries in Carrara

Cemetery in Asmara

The Church

The Churches in Eritrea

Catholic Eparchy in Keren. See "Read More" for the contextualization of religion and nationalism in Eritrea.

Read More
A Church in Carrara, Italy, 2012

Parrocchia Sacra Famiglia, Marina di Carrara. Listen to the audio interview with Don Ercole for more information about Catholicism within modern Italian culture and society.

Don Ercole, parish priest of Falcinello, addresses the current state of the Catholic Church Falcinello, Italy, 2020

download transcript ENG
Asfaha and Tzega Waldu audio interview (ENG)

Friends of Lina and Akos discuss their experience of diaspora, life in the US, and sense of belonging.

Authors' Comments

Themes:

Resources

About this Monograph
About the Authors
Comprehensive Bibliography
Database for this Monograph
Eritrean and Italian Colonial History
Acknowledgements